No Permanent Commission for Women in Combat Formations

No permanent status for women in combat areas, Centre tells SC
Published: Monday, Sep 17, 2012, 20:16 IST
Place: New Delhi | Agency: PTI
The government has told the Supreme Court that it would not be possible to grant permanent commission status to women officers in combat wings like infantry, mechanised infantry and armoured corps.
In an additional affidavit filed before the apex court, the defence ministry has said that combat support arms/ services have to sustain prolonged conflict hazards and hence, there is no question of grant of permanent status to women officer either now or in the future.
The ministry has filed the affidavit in connection with the appeal filed by it challenging the Delhi High Court's March 12, 2010, judgment directing the Centre to grant permanent commission status to women short service commissioned officers in the air force and the army.
The Centre while agreeing to implement the direction with regard to the air force has however, expressed its opposition to extending the benefit to women in the army combat and its support units.
"That the grant of permanent commission to women officers in combat arms like infantry, mechanised infantry and armoured corps, which are involved in direct combat with the enemy is ruled out because of their close proximity with the enemy and attendant hazards of battle.
"As regard granting permanent commission to women officers in combat support arms like engineers, signals, army air defence, intelligence and services like electronics mechanical engineers, army service corps and army ordnance corps, the issue has been examined at length," the Centre said justifying its stance.
No permanent status for women in combat areas, Centre tells SC

Are we worthy of a soldier’s supreme sacrifice

This particular anecdote comes from the archives of The Sunday Indian: a ’straight from the heart’ account of a journalist, Prasoon S. Majumdar, Editor, Economic Affairs, The Sunday Indian.

Around six years ago I traveled to Kerala on some official assignment. I boarded the Kerala Express at New Delhi and knowing that the journey is going to take 54 hours, I was keen to know about my co-passengers. As I boarded the train, I realized that the other six passengers are all men! Out of all them, the eldest and the wittiest, who could effortlessly initiate conversations was an ex-IFS, who had taken a voluntary retirement and was on his own. The next was a LIC agent from Kerala (whose eyes always preyed for potential policy buyers), had come to receive the award for being one of the outstanding performers from the South zone, and now was returning. The third was a serious looking hotelier, a General Manager in a five star property in Delhi, was going to Kerala to meet his parents, who also had seen a girl for him. The fourth was a journalist from Cochin, who commanded profound knowledge of the thriving pornography industry, had come to Delhi to cover some news beats. The fifth one, a soldier from Palaghat, and the most intriguing of all, in fact the protagonist for our long 54 hour journey. And the sixth was – me, the story teller.

The first day of our journey went by discussing politics to pornography, most of it was initiated by the ex – bureaucrat. The only person who stood completely disinterested was our soldier friend. Sitting by the side lower berth he kept on looking outside, got down at every station, and kept asking everyone whether the train is moving at a right time or not. His gestures suggested that if he could, he would run faster than the train to reach his destination. It was only in the later part of the second day that he got a little comfortable with us. He hardly spoke, but whatever he shared left us completely dumbstruck. He started by saying that was on his way back, after almost nine months serving at Siachen. He had not taken a shower in the past six months and had been on a diet of dry fruits and chocolates. We could gather his urgency to reach Palghat, when he told us that he was blessed with a son four months back, and he didn’t even know how he looked! What awed us was this man’s humility, innocence and his genuine ‘going home soon smile’. It never appeared to fade even when he kept on narrating inhuman experiences that hundreds of soldiers like him undergo, while guarding our borders.

By night all of us hit our respective berths. I couldn't sleep as the soldier’s narration kept on reverberating in my mind. From my berth I kept on looking at him and found that he couldn't sleep either. He got up, opened his trunk, and looked at the gifts that he got for his son, took out a small mirror and combed his hair. He repeated the same in a similar sequence innumerable times.

While I read today that on an average one soldier of our Indian Army is giving away their life, once in every three days, on account of mental and physical strain, I am reminded of him. It is him and every soldier like him, who are giving away every bit of their precious life to make us feel secured. Frankly – ‘Are we any worthy of their supreme sacrifice?’
Prasoon S. Majumdar
Editor, Economic Affairs, The Sunday Indian.
Worthy of a Soldier's Supreme Sacrifice?

Comment: The Jawan guarding the nation requires the best weapons, palatable food, quality clothing (winter) and unadulterated Petroleum Products. The MOD task is to monitor these aspects. However due to apathy of bureaucracy and corruption what we see is that the soldier hardly gets his entitlements, rather he is burdened and saddled with poor quality and sub standard personal/ fighting gear. He literally has two fronts to battle first the enemy and second his embittered morale due to poor quality gear and food. The scene is akin to all poverty alleviation programmes, where the beneficiary hardly gets 10% of his entitlement. For every charitable dollar received from abroad by NGO's only 20% reaches the poor. The rest is eaten up by overheads and needless expenses to keep the bureaucrats happy. In our case the defence contractors call the shots!

Lest we Forget

The work horse of Corps of Signals for four decades. These communication stations now have been assigned scrap status by COD Agra. Working sets are now available as museum pieces in the Training Establishments.

IC-25067 2/Lieutenant Arun Khetarpal, PVC, Posthumous

Date: 16 December 1971

Place of Action: Jarpal, Shakargarh Sector

Commissioned: 13 June 1971 (six months before the action)

Unit: 17th Poona Horse

Date and Place of Birth: 14 October 1950, Pune, Maharashtra

Son of Brig M L Khetrapal (Retd)

Full Story of his heroic deeds visit:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arun_Khetarpal

http://www.bharat-rakshak.com/HEROISM/Khetarpal.html

http://faculty.winthrop.edu/haynese/india/medals/PVC/PVC13.html

http://www.sanawar.com/defence.htm

http://forums.sulekha.com/forums/coffeehouse/Valour-has-no-borders-2nd-LtArun-Khetrapal-PVC.htm