A witness who walked tall inspite of the Bureaucrats

By T J S George, 04/10/2010
A witness who walked tall
Out of the blue, as it were, a new and wholly unexpected voice broke above the newspaper din in India in 1959. In a politics-obsessed world, this voice began talking about development projects – Bhakra Nangal, Damodar Valley, Hirakund, Nagarjunsagar – and then about “brand names of distinction” like HAL, HMT, BHEL, ONGC etc. These were all new terms at that time and the overall picture that came through was that of a massive change under way in the thinking as well as structural composition of India. It was as good as a scoop... That was B. G. Verghese's entry into public attention...

His stint as adviser to Indira Gandhi allows him to speak frankly about the reality of high-level activities - how drafts for after-dinner speeches are finalised only after the dinner has started, how the Government does not work out a world view and relies instead on tired slogans, "the haphazard manner in which government functioned and the Prime Minister's inexperience in so many matters".

Verghese' assessment of Indira Gandhi is a highlight of the book. He pays tribute to her qualities of leadership, the dignity of her deportment, her pride in India. But he is unsparing in his condemnation of the Emergency, the "savage and thoroughly illegal demolition orgy" of Sanjay Gandhi and of Indira's own "split personality".

B.G.Verghese is a serious person, concerned with serious, "un-sexy" topics like water resources. That makes his humour more appealing. The quality of his mind is reflected in the lightness with which he describes his introduction to the Prime Minister's Secretariat.

"There was no airconditioner in the room as the previous incumbent was a mere deputy secretary who 'as per rules' was not entitled to feel overly hot. The official theory was that the blood grew thinner with ascending seniority, entitling the officer to one, two or more airconditioners. The same theory worked for arm rests, back rests and foot rests..... Nor did I allow my chaprassi to hover around the car park in the morning to relieve me of my briefcase the moment I arrived. Official research had established that senior officers carry so much responsibility that the weight of a briefcase could do incalculable damage to their spine".

His briefcase tightly held in his own hand, Verghese kept his spine straight and walked tall.
Read More: A witness who walked tall