Field Marshal Manekshaw: Sad Signal to the Soldier

There would be immediate, strong refutal of any suggestion of sinister motives underlying the disturbingly low-key political and military representation at the Sam Manekshaw requiem. Maybe there were none: but that would invite even more worrying interpretations ~ of indifference, ingratitude. Either way, what transpired in the Nilgiris was indicative of how, as a nation and a people, we have abandoned all graces. To extend that sentiment (rather, absence of it) even further, of re-confirmation that our military attracts only jingoistic lip-service.

The defence minister claims prior political engagements, an indication of priorities. The navy and air force chiefs (the army chief is abroad) have offered no public explanation. Yet had the Prime Minister opted to visit Wellington and pay homage ~ as Indira Gandhi would certainly have done (Manekshaw made one of his rare trips to New Delhi for her cremation) ~ a host of others would have followed. That Sam was sinking was evident at least 24 hours before he eventually laid down his sword and shield, time enough for schedules to be reworked. Comparisons suck, but had a political figure passed away the national leadership would have gone beyond issuing condolence messages and sending wreaths. Manekshaw was not just a successful military man, he was a national icon who at one point in time was held in such esteem that the politicians got jittery. But great soldier that he was, he never sought to transgress the defining lines of political, civilian and military responsibilities. Recognition of just that single facet of his myriad personality ought to have caused those making pretence to leadership to salute him one last time.

Regretfully, it is not just Sam who has been slighted. The defence community, already under severe strain, might well “see” that against the backdrop of being overworked, underpaid and generally ignored by the powers-that-be. Already some retired officers are expressing dismay, those still in service must suffer in silence. The impact on morale can only be negative. Yet if there was a single point to Manekshaw’s magic it was that he kept morale sky-high. Admittedly attending a funeral is essentially a gesture, but in a community like the military where the heart rules as much as the head, gestures have wholesome impact.

Can amends be made? In all humility The Statesman would make bold to recommend that, with the approval of his family, a selection of Manekshaw’s effects be brought to the Capital and constitute the core of the long overdue National War Memorial. Other nations pay homage at the tomb of the Unknown Soldier; we can honour our military martyrs around memorabilia of our most hallowed one.

Editorial from The Statesman Tuesday, 1 July 2008

Graceless, demeaning: Sad Signal to the Soldier

Comment: This article has been reproduced as it echos the sentiments of all ESM and Serving Soldiers. The best tribute would be an edifice to honour each and every Soldier. This can only be the National War Memorial which is still eluding the Nation.